Do Students Learn Less When They Use Their Phones in Class or While Studying?

Probably, a little, and the effect looks larger for students who already struggle. The evidence comes from a small lab experiment and a study of school phone bans, so it points one way without settling the question.

Matthew KFounder, FellaBlog

Short answer

Phone use during teaching is linked to worse learning in the studies below, but the evidence is thin and each study tests something different.

One experiment put students in front of a video lecture and varied how much texting-like activity they did. Another study looked at what happened to exam results in English schools after phones were banned. Both found harm from phone use, and neither tested what happens when you study alone with your phone nearby.

The lecture experiment

Kuznekoff and Titsworth (2013) had students watch a video lecture and take notes, then complete two learning tests. Participants were split into a control group, a low-distraction group and a high-distraction group, where the distraction was texting or posting activity during the lecture. After excluding participants with technical problems, 47 students remained: 19 control, 14 low-distraction and 14 high-distraction. They were aged 18 to 22.

The abstract reports that students who were not using their phones wrote down 62 percent more information in their notes, took more detailed notes, recalled more detail from the lecture and scored a full letter grade and a half higher on a multiple-choice test than students who were actively using their phones. The authors' discussion puts the cost of texting in rough terms: potentially 38 percent fewer details in notes, 51 percent lower on free recall and 20 percent lower on multiple choice.

Notes also mattered on their own. The authors found moderate to strong correlations between how many details students recorded and how they scored on the tests.

What happened when schools banned phones

Beland and Murphy (2016, Labour Economics) surveyed schools in four English cities about their mobile phone policies and combined the answers with national exam data. They compared schools that introduced bans with schools that did not, before and after. The published abstract says exam performance rose by about 0.07 standard deviations on average after a ban. The 2015 working paper reported 6.41 percent of a standard deviation. We read abstracts and write-ups, not the full paper.

The gains were concentrated among lower-achieving students, and the authors conclude that restricting phones can be a low-cost way to reduce educational inequality. An LSE summary adds that the effect for high achievers was not significant, and that for 14-year-olds there was no significant effect either way, possibly because phone use is lower at that age.

How far to trust this

  • Small experiment. The lecture study had 47 participants, mostly first-year students, and a short video, not a semester.
  • Simulated texting. The activity was built for the experiment, so real habits may differ.
  • Bans are not random. The English study compares schools over time. Schools that chose bans may differ in other ways, which the authors address with their design but cannot rule out entirely.
  • Different questions. The first looks at live distraction in a lecture and the second at a school-wide policy. Neither tests studying alone at home.
  • Related work is mixed. Research on a phone merely sitting nearby has produced mixed results, which we cover in does keeping your phone in another room help you focus.

What to do with it

These steps are our suggestions, not findings from the studies.

Phones and learning FAQ

In one lab experiment, students who texted or posted during a video lecture wrote less detailed notes and did worse on recall and multiple-choice tests. A study of school phone bans in England found modest exam gains after bans, mostly among lower-achieving students.

The published abstract says about 0.07 standard deviations on average, concentrated among lower-achieving students. The 2015 working paper reported 6.41 percent of a standard deviation.

It is suggestive, not settled. The lecture experiment had 47 participants, and the ban study compared schools over time rather than assigning students at random.

Try silencing and moving the phone out of reach during a study block and compare how much you finish. That is our suggestion, not a finding of these studies.

References

  • Kuznekoff, J. H., & Titsworth, S. (2013). The impact of mobile phone usage on student learning. Communication Education, 62(3), 233-252. DOI. We read the full text.
  • Beland, L.-P., & Murphy, R. (2016). Ill communication: technology, distraction and student performance. Labour Economics, 41, 61-76. Record and LSE discussion paper abstract. We read abstracts and summaries, not the full paper.