Attention Residue: Why a Quick Phone Check Costs More Than 10 Seconds

Leaving a task does not always switch your attention off it. Research on task switching suggests some of it can stay behind. Nobody has timed what that costs after a phone check, so treat the 10 seconds as a question, not a measurement.

Matthew KFounder, FellaBlog

Short answer

A check takes seconds on the clock, but the task you left may keep part of your attention for longer.

That leftover is called attention residue. Sophie Leroy described it in 2009: when people switch tasks, they have difficulty moving their attention away from an unfinished one, and the next task suffers. Her experiments did not use phones, and none of the sources used here measure how long a phone check lasts. The link is an extension of the finding, a reasonable one, but still an extension.

What attention residue means

Switching tasks looks instant from the outside. You open a message, read it, go back to the document. The idea behind attention residue is that your mind does not switch as cleanly as your screen does. Part of it can still be on the message while you try to work on the document.

Leroy's paper, Why is it so hard to do my work? The challenge of attention residue when switching between work tasks, studies jobs where people move between projects, tasks and meetings. Its central claim is that to perform well on a new task, you need to stop thinking about the previous one, and that this is hard when the previous one is unfinished.

What the experiments found

There were two lab experiments with university students. Participants did a word task first, then a second task. In the first experiment the second task was a lexical decision task, where you judge whether a string of letters is a real word, and quicker responses to words from the first task signal attention still lingering there. In the second experiment it was a résumé appraisal. A BPS Research Digest summary reports 84 and 78 students in the two experiments.

Three results stand out:

  • Unfinished tasks leave more behind. People who could not finish the first task showed more residue and did worse on the next one.
  • Finishing was not enough on its own. People who finished without time pressure still had lingering attention.
  • Finishing under time pressure helped. Those who finished the first task under a short deadline showed less residue, did better on the next task and were more confident they had completed the first. Leroy's explanation is a sense of cognitive closure.

What the study does not show

The limits matter more here than in most posts, because the headline idea travels further than the evidence.

  • No phones. The tasks were a word task, lexical decisions and résumé appraisal.
  • No stopwatch. The paper does not put a number on how long residue lasts, so "more than 10 seconds" is our framing, not a result.
  • Students in a lab. Time pressure was created by a short limit and instructions, which is not the same as a real deadline at work.
  • Self-reported confidence. One of the measures was how sure people felt that they had completed the first task.

Follow-up work by Leroy and Aaron Schmidt (2016) extended the idea to interruptions. If you want the research on phones specifically, we cover it separately in does keeping your phone in another room help you focus, where the findings are mixed.

Why a phone check is a likely case

A quick check has the ingredients the experiments point to. You leave a task before it is finished, you land on something that has its own open loops (a message to answer, a feed with no end), and you come back to the first task without any sense that it was wrapped up.

That is our reading, not a tested result. It also explains why checks that end at a clear stopping point, such as one reply sent, may feel less costly than checks that trail off into scrolling. We have not seen research that compares the two, so hold that loosely.

For the related idea in our glossary, see attention residue.

What to do about it

Only the first point below comes from Leroy's experiments. The rest are suggestions that follow from the idea, and you should test them on your own work.

  • Reach a stopping point before you switch. In the experiments, completing a task under time pressure reduced residue. A short, set time box for a task is one way to get closure.
  • Batch your checks. Fewer switches means fewer chances to leave something half done. Pick two or three moments in a work block instead of checking whenever you feel the pull.
  • Write down where you stopped. A one-line note ("next: fix the second paragraph") is a cheap way to mark an open loop as handled.
  • Make the check harder to start. If you reach for your phone without deciding to, put distance or friction in the way. An app blocker with a schedule does this for the apps that pull you away most; see our free iPhone app blockers compared.

Attention residue FAQ

It is the part of your attention that stays on a previous task after you switch to a new one. Sophie Leroy introduced the idea in 2009, finding that people have difficulty moving their attention away from an unfinished task, which lowers performance on the next one.

Possibly, but no source here timed a phone check. The claim is an extension of the task-switching research: if a check pulls your attention away and you return before the first task feels finished, some attention may stay behind.

In Leroy's experiments, finishing the first task under time pressure reduced it, while finishing without pressure did not. Batching checks, keeping the phone out of reach in focus blocks and noting where you stopped are practical suggestions, not tested findings.

No. It looked at switching between work tasks in lab experiments with students, using a word task, a lexical decision task and a résumé appraisal.

References

  • Leroy, S. (2009). Why is it so hard to do my work? The challenge of attention residue when switching between work tasks. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 109(2), 168-181. Bibliographic record and abstract. We read the abstract, not the full paper.
  • British Psychological Society Research Digest, The surprising benefits of time pressure at work. Source for the sample sizes, the task descriptions and the time-pressure result.
  • Leroy, S., & Schmidt, A. M. (2016). The effect of regulatory focus on attention residue and performance during interruptions. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 137, 218-235. Listing only; we did not read it.