Do Notifications Make You Check Your Phone More? What Studies Found

The studies mostly measure something else: what alerts do to your attention. They suggest alerts cost focus, but the one trial that switched them all off found people checked more, not less.

Matthew KFounder, FellaBlog

Short answer

Notifications seem to cost attention, and turning every one of them off does not clearly fix it.

Few experiments count how often people pick up their phones. The four below look at attention, inattention symptoms, wellbeing and, in one case, self-reported checking. Alerts on all day were worse for attention. Alerts off for a day made some people more anxious and made them check more. Alerts delivered three times a day did best in one trial.

What the experiments found

A notification alone (Stothart et al., 2015). Participants were randomly assigned to receive a call, a text message or no notification on their own phones while doing a sustained attention task. Those who received a notification made more errors than those who did not, even though they did not answer. Press summaries put the size of the effect close to the cost of actually using the phone. We read only the citation and summaries of this paper, not the full text.

A week with alerts on, a week with them off (Kushlev et al., 2016). 221 undergraduates at the University of British Columbia spent one week keeping notification alerts on with the phone within sight or reach, and another week with alerts off and the phone away. They reported higher inattention and hyperactivity symptoms in the alerts-on week. At baseline, students who reported feeling more interrupted by notifications also reported more inattention (a correlation of .31) and hyperactivity (.30). The authors found no direct effect of the manipulation on productivity or psychological well-being, and note that participants knew which condition they were in, so their answers may reflect what they expected.

Batching (Fitz et al., 2019). 237 smartphone owners recruited through an online labor market took part in a two week field experiment with a custom Android app. Notifications arrived as usual, in batches three times a day, in hourly batches, or not at all. Batching three times a day improved stress, productivity and mood, and the authors found the benefit was mediated by less inattention. Hourly batches did not. Getting no notifications did not improve inattention and instead raised anxiety, which the authors linked to fear of missing out.

A day with no alerts (Pielot and Rello, 2017). 30 volunteers turned off notifications on all their devices for 24 hours and compared that day with a normal one. They felt less distracted and more productive. They also felt less able to respond as people expected, worried more about missing information, felt less connected to their social group, and reported checking their phone more (a modest effect, p = .031). Stress did not differ.

Where the results disagree

  • Checking. The only study here that asked about checking found it rose when notifications were off. People may check on their own because they cannot rely on being told.
  • Attention. Kushlev found less inattention with alerts off. Fitz found no attention gain from no notifications, while batching did help.
  • Wellbeing. Pielot found no stress difference. Fitz found lower stress and better mood with three daily batches, and more anxiety with none.

Differences in design probably explain some of it: a day, a week and two weeks, different groups and different measures.

Limits to keep in mind

  • Self-reports. Most outcomes are what people said about their day.
  • Short and narrow. Studies lasted from 24 hours to two weeks. Kushlev's sample was university students and Fitz's was smartphone owners in India recruited online. Fitz's authors say longer trials are needed and that not all notifications are equally important.
  • Not a clinical claim. Kushlev's team says neither that phones cause ADHD nor that cutting notifications treats it.
  • No count of pickups. None of these studies logged how often people unlocked their phones.

What to try

These are our suggestions, built on the batching result rather than taken from it.

Notifications and attention FAQ

Experiments suggest they can. A notification alone was followed by worse performance on an attention task, and students reported more inattention in a week with alerts on than with them off.

Not in the one study that measured it. People without notifications for 24 hours felt less distracted but reported checking their phone more, and some felt anxious about missing things.

Batching. In a two week trial, notifications delivered three times a day improved stress, productivity and mood, while hourly batches did not and receiving none raised anxiety.

Suggestive. The studies are short, partly self-reported and use students or online workers, and they measure different things.

References

  • Stothart, C., Mitchum, A., & Yehnert, C. (2015). The attentional cost of receiving a cell phone notification. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 41(4), 893-897. DOI. Citation and press summaries only; we did not read the full text.
  • Kushlev, K., Proulx, J., & Dunn, E. W. (2016). "Silence your phones": smartphone notifications increase inattention and hyperactivity symptoms. Proceedings of CHI 2016, 1011-1020. Paper. Read in full.
  • Fitz, N., Kushlev, K., Jagannathan, R., Lewis, T., Paliwal, D., & Ariely, D. (2019). Batching smartphone notifications can improve well-being. Computers in Human Behavior, 101, 84-94. DOI. Read in full.
  • Pielot, M., & Rello, L. (2017). Productive, anxious, lonely: 24 hours without push notifications. MobileHCI 2017. arXiv preprint. Read in full.