Does Using Your Phone During a Meal Make It Less Enjoyable? What the Studies Found

One field experiment says yes: diners with phones on the table enjoyed the meal less. Studies on a phone that is merely nearby disagree, so the evidence points at use, not presence.

Matthew KFounder, FellaBlog

Short answer

Using your phone at a meal seems to cost some enjoyment, a small amount. A silent phone sitting nearby is a much weaker claim.

The best evidence is a field experiment in a cafe. The strongest counter-evidence is a replication that failed to find that a phone's mere presence harms conversation. They test different things, which is why they can both be right.

The cafe experiment

Dwyer, Kushlev and Dunn (2018, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology) invited groups of three to five friends or family members to have a meal at a local cafe. 304 people took part, aged 19 to 69, and the study was pre-registered. Each group was randomly assigned a condition. In the phone condition, people were told to put their phones on the table with the ringer or vibration on, because a researcher would text them a survey question. In the phoneless condition, people silenced their phones and put them in a container on the table. Coders watched the meals and found phones were in use about 11 percent of the time in the phone groups and 1 percent in the phoneless groups.

Afterwards, people in the phone groups reported lower interest and enjoyment, and more distraction. They also reported somewhat more boredom. TIME's coverage describes the enjoyment drop as about half a point on a seven-point scale, and the lead author calls it small.

A second study asked people about their social interactions across a week and found phone use went along with feeling more distracted and enjoying interactions less. That study could not say which came first.

Studies on a phone that is only there

A separate line of work asks a different question: does a phone's presence, with no one touching it, change a conversation?

  • Przybylski and Weinstein (2013). Pairs of strangers chatted for 10 minutes with either a phone or a notebook on a nearby table. According to the British Psychological Society's summary, those with a phone felt less closely related to their partner, and the usual boost in closeness and trust from talking about meaningful events was missing.
  • Misra and colleagues (2016). A coffee shop study of pairs that, as described in a later paper, found lower connectedness and empathy when a mobile device was present. It was observational.
  • Linares and Sellier (2021). A replication in PLoS ONE with 356 participants in 136 groups followed the 2013 procedure. In both experiments the authors "failed to replicate the original results on relationship quality," and found no effect on creativity. They conclude the effect is at minimum harder to find than previously assumed.
  • Courtright and Caplan (2020). The replication paper reports that this meta-analysis of only six studies concluded the mere presence effect is overall unsupported.

Why they differ

  • Use versus presence. The cafe study had alerts on and people using their phones. The replication tested a nondescript phone sitting still.
  • Real life versus lab. The cafe study ran in a real setting with friends and family. The presence studies used strangers or short conversations.
  • Small early samples. The replication notes that the original studies were small.

Limits to keep in mind

  • Own phone or everyone's? Whole groups were assigned a condition, so the cafe study cannot tell whether the cost comes from your own phone use, your companions' use, or both. Its authors say so.
  • Small effect. Half a point on a seven-point scale is easy to miss in a normal meal.
  • Self-reports. Enjoyment and distraction were what people said.
  • Our reading. We read the cafe paper and the replication paper's text. For Przybylski and Weinstein we used the BPS summary, and for Misra and for Courtright and Caplan we used how the replication paper describes them.

What to do with it

The only intervention the cafe study tested directly was silencing phones and putting them away for the meal, and that group did better. The rest below is our suggestion.

  • Silence it and put it away, rather than leaving it face down on the table with alerts on.
  • Agree on it as a group. If one person uses a phone, others may feel it. Our how to stop using your phone while eating guide has practical ways to do this.
  • Block the apps that pull you in for the length of dinner with a scheduled block, so the decision is made before you sit down.

Phones at the table FAQ

In a field experiment with 304 people, diners reported lower interest and enjoyment and more distraction when phones were on the table with alerts on than when phones were silenced and put away.

It is disputed. An early study found strangers felt less connected with a phone nearby, but a 2021 replication with 356 participants did not reproduce it.

The cafe study cannot separate them, because whole groups were assigned to a condition.

Silence the phone and put it away for the meal, which is the condition that did better in the cafe experiment.

References

  • Dwyer, R. J., Kushlev, K., & Dunn, E. W. (2018). Smartphone use undermines enjoyment of face-to-face social interactions. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 78, 233-239. DOI. Read the paper's text. The half-point figure is from TIME's coverage.
  • Linares, S., & Sellier, A.-L. (2021). How bad is the mere presence of a phone? A replication of Przybylski and Weinstein (2013) and an extension to creativity. PLoS ONE. Full text.
  • Przybylski, A. K., & Weinstein, N. (2013). Can you connect with me now? How the presence of mobile communication technology influences face-to-face conversation quality. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 30(3), 237-246. Summary: BPS Research Digest.
  • Misra, S., Cheng, L., Genevie, J., & Yuan, M. (2016). The iPhone effect: the quality of in-person social interactions in the presence of mobile devices. Environment and Behavior, 48(2), 275-298. Described in the replication paper; we did not read it.
  • Courtright, J. A., & Caplan, S. E. (2020). A meta-analysis of mobile phone use and presence. Human Communication & Technology, 1(2), 20-35. Described in the replication paper; we did not read it.