Do If-Then Plans Help You Use Your Phone Less? What the Research on Implementation Intentions Found

If-then plans have a strong record for getting people to do what they intend. Whether they cut phone use is much less settled, because few studies have tested it.

Matthew KFounder, FellaBlog

Short answer

A large body of research says if-then plans help people reach goals. Direct evidence for phone use is thin and mixed.

The main source is a meta-analysis by Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006) that pooled 94 tests of goals in general. Phone studies are few, and the ones we found concern drivers, not everyday use.

What an implementation intention is

An implementation intention is an if-then plan that links a specific situation to a specific response. The US National Cancer Institute's research page describes them as plans that tie situational cues to responses that help reach a goal, formed to help people turn a goal into action. A goal says "I want to use my phone less." A plan says "If it is 9 pm, then my phone goes on the charger in the hall."

What the meta-analysis found

Gollwitzer and Sheeran's review, Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis of effects and processes (2006), reports findings from 94 independent tests. The effect of an if-then plan on goal attainment was positive and of medium-to-large size, d = .65. The NCI page credits the same review with d = .61 for getting started on a goal and d = .77 for preventing derailment.

The abstract says the plans helped people start pursuing a goal, shield it from unwanted influences, disengage from failing courses of action and conserve capability for later goal striving. It reports support for two processes: a plan makes the specified cue easier to notice, and it makes the response more automatic.

How big is d = .65? Our arithmetic, not the paper's: if scores are roughly normally distributed, there is about a 68 percent chance that a random person who made a plan did better than a random person who did not. It is a clear effect, not a guarantee.

When it works best. The NCI page says the effects are stronger when the person has a strong, active goal and when there is a real self-regulatory problem to overcome. When there are few barriers, a plan may be unnecessary. It also says effectiveness depends on how precise and workable the plan is.

What we know about phones

  • Drivers, 2021. A randomized trial by Elliott and colleagues is titled "Evidence that implementation intentions reduce drivers' use of mobile phones while driving." We could not open the paper, so we cannot report its numbers.
  • Drivers, 2025. A follow-up trial of 436 people compared a planning sheet, the sheet plus extra reinforcement of the plan, and an active control. It found no post-intervention differences between arms on standard self-report measures of phone use while driving. In an exploratory analysis, people in the reinforcement arm who recalled their plans more accurately cut phone use more.
  • Everyday use. A 2025 randomized trial of a planning intervention to reduce smartphone time in university students exists (Brockmeier and colleagues), but we could not read its results.

That is a thin and mixed picture. The 2025 result suggests that making a plan is not enough if you do not remember it when the moment comes.

How to write a plan

The format comes from the research. The examples are ours.

  1. Start with a goal you care about. The effect was strongest when the goal intention was strong.
  2. Pick a specific cue, a time, place or situation where you slip. "When I get into bed" beats "in the evening."
  3. Pick a specific response you can do in the moment. "Then I will put the phone on the charger across the room."
  4. Use the if-then format, as the NCI page stresses: "If I sit down to work, then I will put my phone in the drawer." "If I notice my thumb opening an app with no reason, then I will lock the phone and take one breath."
  5. Make it precise and doable. Vague plans do not help.
  6. Re-read it. The 2025 trial points to remembering the plan as a possible weak spot.

Plans still rely on you remembering to act. A scheduled app block handles the cue for you at set times, which we explain in reduce social media use with schedules.

Limits to keep in mind

  • The meta-analysis is about goals in general, from exercise to studying, not phone use.
  • Phone evidence is thin, and one of the two driving trials we found had null results.
  • We did not read the meta-analysis in full. We read its abstract and the NCI page summarizing it. The NCI page says it is no longer maintained and may be outdated.

If-then plans FAQ

An if-then plan linking a specific situation to a specific response, like "If I sit down to work, then I will put my phone in the drawer."

A meta-analysis of 94 independent tests found a positive effect of medium-to-large size (d = .65) on goal attainment.

The evidence is thin. A 2021 trial on drivers reported a reduction, and a 2025 trial found no difference between its arms.

Name a specific situation and a specific response in an if-then format, aim at the moments you usually slip, and keep it precise and doable.

References

  • Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: a meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69-119. DOI. Abstract record. We read the abstract.
  • US National Cancer Institute, Implementation intentions: definition, the d = .61 and d = .77 figures, and the moderators. The page notes it is no longer maintained.
  • Elliott, M. A., et al. (2025). A randomised controlled trial testing the efficacy of a volitional help sheet. Transportation Research Part F, 115, 103339. Abstract record. We read the abstract.
  • Elliott, M. A., et al. (2021). Evidence that implementation intentions reduce drivers' use of mobile phones while driving. Transportation Research Part F. We did not read it.
  • Brockmeier et al. (2025). A planning intervention to reduce smartphone use. Computers in Human Behavior. DOI. We did not read it.