On the evidence provided, no — and the question has not been directly tested.
Yang’s experiment studied TikTok specifically: 15 minutes of TikTok led to distorted estimates. It did not include a Reels or Shorts arm, so it cannot say whether TikTok differs from the others. Jiang’s comparison was short-video versus reading, not TikTok versus Reels versus Shorts. There, video was not consistently different from reading, which argues against a unique video-format penalty, let alone a TikTok-specific one.
That does not make the platforms identical in daily life. Recommendation, length defaults, and interface details differ across TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts, and those could shape habits over weeks. But for the specific outcome of felt time after brief viewing, the studies at hand point to shared factors — absorption, duration, and habitual use — rather than a platform that uniquely steals time.
Until a study directly contrasts TikTok, Reels, and Shorts in the same paradigm with the same estimation task, the cautious claim is that the three look more similar than different for time distortion.